[1st] Edition Vintage

[1st] Edition Vintage[1st] Edition Vintage[1st] Edition Vintage
Home
Sell Your Collection
The Vault

[1st] Edition Vintage

[1st] Edition Vintage[1st] Edition Vintage[1st] Edition Vintage
Home
Sell Your Collection
The Vault
More
  • Home
  • Sell Your Collection
  • The Vault
  • Sign In

  • My Account
  • Signed in as:

  • filler@godaddy.com


  • My Account
  • Sign out


Signed in as:

filler@godaddy.com

  • Home
  • Sell Your Collection
  • The Vault

Account

  • My Account
  • Sign out

  • Sign In
  • My Account

Turn Your Vintage Into Capital

The "What We Buy" Checklist

Vintage Pokémon (1999–2003)

 1st Edition Base Set, Shadowless, Crystal Types, Shining Cards, and Gold Stars. 

High-End Slabs

 PSA, BGS, and CGC Graded cards (Grades 8–10 preferred). 

Nintendo Hardware

 Game Boy (DMG, Color, Advance), N64, GameCube (Special Editions preferred). 

Sealed Product

 Vintage Booster Packs, Sealed Theme Decks, and Sealed Games. 

The 3-Step Process

Submit Your List

Submit Your List

Submit Your List

 Fill out the form below with photos and a brief description of condition. 

Receive an Offer

Submit Your List

Submit Your List

 We review your submission within 24 hours and send a cash offer or store credit bonus (20% extra). 

Ship & Get Paid

Submit Your List

Ship & Get Paid

 Ship your items (insured). Once verified, payment is released same-day via PayPal or Bank Wire. 

Condition Guidelines ("The Tough Truths")

 "Condition is King." We pay premium rates for Near Mint (NM) and Mint raw cards. Please reach us at support@vintagegoldstarcards.com if you cannot find an answer to your question.

  Clean surface, sharp corners, minimal whitening. 


  We buy rare vintage in played condition, but offers will reflect the market value for that grade. 


 Water damaged, creased, or fake items. 


TERMS OF SALE & RETURN POLICY

Effective Date: November 29, 2025

By completing a purchase on First Edition Vintage, the Buyer explicitly agrees to the following terms and conditions. Please read them carefully before finalizing your order.

1. All Sales Are Final

Due to the volatile nature of the collectibles market and the high value of our inventory, we do not offer cash refunds for any purchases. This policy applies strictly to all:

  • Graded Trading Cards (Slabs)
  • Video Game Consoles and Hardware
  • Sealed Software

2. Store Credit Exchange Option

While we do not offer cash refunds, we understand that collection goals change. We may, at our sole discretion, accept a return in exchange for Store Credit.

  • If a return is authorized, the full purchase amount will be issued as a digital First Edition Vintage Gift Card.
  • This credit never expires and is usable site-wide for any future inventory drops.
  • To initiate a credit request, the item must be returned in the exact condition it was sent, with no evidence of tampering to the slab, case, or seal.

3. Product Condition & "As Is" Agreement

All items listed on the site are sold "As Is."

  • We provide high-resolution imagery and accurate descriptions, including certification numbers for graded items.
  • By purchasing, the Buyer acknowledges that they have reviewed the item description and images and accepts the item in its stated condition.
  • We make no guarantees regarding future grading potential (e.g., "regrading" or "crossing over" to other authentication companies).

4. Shipping, Liability, and Transfer of Ownership

  • Signature Confirmation: All orders are shipped with mandatory Signature Confirmation.
  • Transfer of Ownership: Ownership of the item legally transfers to the Buyer the moment the package is signed for at the delivery address provided.
  • Carrier Liability: First Edition Vintage is not liable for packages lost, stolen, or damaged during transit once the package has been handed over to the shipping carrier.
  • Post-Delivery: We are not liable for any damage occurred to the item after the shipment has been tendered to the carrier or after the item has been signed for.

SHOP NOW

Submit Your Items for Review

Complete the form below with a detailed list and clear photos. Vague descriptions lead to conservative estimates—accuracy ensures you get the premium offer your collection deserves. We review all serious inquiries within 24 hours.

Attach Files
Attachments (0)

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

The Best Deals Never Hit The Public Site.

  Get priority access to our updated "Buy List" rates and exclusive "First Dibs" alerts on fresh inventory drops before they go live. 

First Edition Vintage

Colorado Springs, CO 80907, USA

support@vintagegoldstarcards.com

Hours

Mon

09:00 am – 05:00 pm

Tue

09:00 am – 05:00 pm

Wed

09:00 am – 05:00 pm

Thu

09:00 am – 05:00 pm

Fri

09:00 am – 05:00 pm

Sat

Closed

Sun

Closed

Copyright © 2025 First Edition Vintage - All Rights Reserved.

Powered by

  • Sell Your Collection
  • The Vault
  • Nintendo
  • Pokemon